Excel or a wine cellar app: which is better
An Excel sheet works for a wine cellar while the bottles are few. When to switch to a wine cellar management app, on your phone and on your computer.
Why most people start with Excel
Almost everyone starts with a spreadsheet, and rightly so: it’s free, you already know it, and you add whatever columns you like. For a dozen bottles it’s the right answer. The trouble comes later, when the cellar grows and the sheet stays on the home computer. This is an honest comparison between an Excel sheet for your wine cellar and a wine cellar management app: where Excel is still the better choice, and where an app saves you time.
Where Excel still wins
- Total freedom. Columns, formulas, pivot tables, charts: do whatever you want, without asking an app for permission.
- It costs nothing, if you already have the program.
If your collection is small, you like being in control and you almost always use the same computer, a well-made sheet can be enough. There’s no need to complicate your life.
Where an app is more comfortable
The difference shows up mostly on the move: in the cellar, in front of the shelf, at the restaurant or in the wine shop.
| Aspect | Excel sheet | Cellar app (Beviamolo) |
|---|---|---|
| Adding a bottle | ✗ Type every field by hand | ✓ Photograph the label: the AI fills in producer, vintage, appellation |
| From the phone, in the cellar | ✗ Tiny cells, constant scrolling | ✓ Built for the phone, with search and filters |
| Finding where a bottle is | ✗ Find a row, then remember the shelf | ✓ A cellar grid with coordinates: it tells you “A3” |
| When to drink it | ✗ You work it out and remember it | ✓ Drinking window; on Android the alerts arrive even with the app closed |
| What to pair tonight | ✗ Not there | ✓ Describe the dish, the app picks from the bottles you own |
| If the computer breaks | ✗ The file lives there: if the disk burns out, the file gets corrupted or a virus arrives, the cellar goes with it | ✓ The cellar lives on your account, with backups: change phone or computer, log in and it’s all there |
| Without a connection | ✓ If the file is on the device | ✓ You can save offline too: it syncs when the network returns |
| On the computer | ✓ Any spreadsheet program | ✓ Native app for Windows and Linux, plus Android |
| Sharing | ✗ You send the whole file | ✓ Lists by link or PDF, only with the fields you choose |
| Freedom of structure | ✓ Total | ✗ Fixed fields, simpler |
The phone is where the sheet gives up
A cellar is used standing up, with a bottle in your hand. An Excel sheet on a phone makes you zoom, scroll and tap tiny cells. In Beviamolo you open the wine’s record, see its position in the cellar grid and mark it as opened in a few taps. On the computer the same cellar fills the screen: list, filters and record side by side.
The file you won’t find in ten years
An Excel sheet is a file on a computer, and files disappear: they get deleted by mistake, they get corrupted, the disk fails or the computer catches a virus. Often it isn’t even about accidents: in ten years, will you remember which folder you put it in, or on which old computer? If you keep it on a cloud service or make regular copies the risk drops a lot, but you have to remember to do it. In Beviamolo the cellar lives on your account and you find it from any phone or computer with the same login, with no files to manage.
Moving from the sheet to the app without retyping everything
You don’t have to start from scratch. Import your Excel or CSV file: the app matches your columns to its fields, looks up the wines it doesn’t know and lets you review the uncertain ones. It never adds anything without your confirmation. If the file is a mess (it happens), you can also photograph the bottles and have them recognised.
Coming soon
These are not available yet, planned for the next versions:
- An iPhone app and a Mac app. Today Beviamolo runs on Android, Windows and Linux.
- The restaurant wine list: you photograph the pages of the list and Beviamolo suggests a pick among the wines it read, based on your budget and the tastes in your cellar. The list isn’t saved on the server.
- Bottles in your cellar and wishlist you can share, with a web page that opens without the app, and a preview of lists on the website.
- Premium: today it’s a waiting list.
When it makes sense to keep Excel
If you have few bottles or need a structure entirely your own, stay on Excel. If you find you’ve stopped updating the sheet because it’s awkward, keep rebuying bottles you already own, or can’t tell where the one you’re after is, it’s time to try an app.